Ryan Day scrutinized for 1-4 Ohio State record vs. Michigan in ESPN top 10 coaches rankings

Zain Bando

Ryan Day scrutinized for 1-4 Ohio State record vs. Michigan in ESPN top 10 coaches rankings image

Adam Cairns/Columbus Dispatch / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

Three months separate Ohio State from a possible repeat-type national title season, which would give coach Ryan Day further validation that his coaching tenure in Columbus justified a contract extension at the end of last season.

Although winning a national title put the Buckeyes at the top of college football, not everyone recognizes Day as the sport's best coach.

This includes ESPN, which released its top 10 coaches list Friday morning with Day receiving the No. 2 spot behind Georgia's Kirby Smart.

Even though Day's team made history by becoming the first to win a national title, his head-to-head record in "The Game" against the Wolverines prevents him from laying claim to the top spot.

Although Day's placement is stellar, one voter, Andrea Adelson, took issue with Day's shortcomings and placed him at No. 4 before everything was finalized.

"There are a couple of reasons I did not rank Day higher," Adelson said. "I think he should be docked for having a poor record against Michigan, the most important game on the schedule every year."

📲 Follow The Sporting News on WhatsApp  

Adelson cited Day as having arguably his best team this past season while still failing to beat the Wolverines as a three-touchdown favorite in Columbus.

"He is 1-4 against the Wolverines and lost last season as a prohibitive favorite," Adelson added. "The corresponding outrage from the fan base only died down after Ohio State won the national championship. That leads me to my second point. You might be thinking the national title is reason enough to have Day ranked higher. But in any other season, that Michigan loss would have ended the Buckeyes' season."

Adelson said, given the new format, the Buckeyes were given a "second chance" at winning it all.

While that may be true, it seems apparent that the Buckeyes were the best team once the College Football Playoff once it began.

Former quarterback Will Howard even admitted, along with former Buckeyes linebacker Jack Sawyer, that winning a national title meant more.

If that's the case, Day's players, past or present, know him best. At the end of the day, whether it's No. 1, No. 2, or No. 4, Ohio State won when it counted.

Entering August, it's bulletin board material for the Buckeyes: they cannot and should not be counted out.

Period.

Zain Bando

Zain Bando is a freelance writer for The Sporting News. He is a graduate of the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign and Northwestern's Medill School of Journalism. Over the years, Bando has written about various beats surrounding Illinois, Northwestern, and Kansas State Athletics but sticks to the Big Ten as his primary expertise. Outside of collegiate reporting, Bando covers MMA and boxing for MMA Knockout On Sports Illustrated and hosts/co-hosts two podcasts as part of the Empty The Bench Podcast Network – Bando's Breakdowns and The MMA Outsiders, which air weekly on YouTube and are distributed on all podcast platforms Wednesday nights and Friday afternoons. Bando is a Chicago Suburban native and a member of the FWAA and USBWA, continuing to hone his professional skills as a sports journalist and media personality. Since June 2019, Bando's byline has been featured in numerous media outlets, including MSN, Yardbarker, Deadspin, FanSided, BJPenn.com, Bridge Media Network (Sports News Highlights), Mike Farrell Sports, Reuters, and more. When Bando is not writing, he binges on old UFC fights, spends time with family and friends, memorizes every Super Bowl, and manifests all the places he still has to travel to (even while bringing his laptop).